Skip to content
Aerial view of Long Beach and Lido Beach on Long Island's south shore

Investor-friendly real estate agents in Long Island, NY

We match investors with vetted Long Island-area agents who own rentals, run the numbers, and know the local rules. Free for investors.

Get matched in Long Island
4
investing strategies covered
Long Beach and Lido Beach, barrier-island communities on Nassau County's south shore.. Photo: formulanone, CC BY-SA 2.0
Who you'll work with

Vetted investor agents across the Long Island metro

Long Island is a high-price, high-tax market where rentals rarely cash flow and New York's tenant rules are among the strictest in the country. Nassau and Suffolk sit just east of New York City, with Long Island Rail Road commutes and little new housing, which keeps prices high. At those prices and with Long Island property taxes, a median-priced rental won't cover a mortgage; investors here are mostly buying equity through renovation, BRRRR, new construction or land. Towns and villages, not the county, set most rental permit and short-term rental rules, and the East End towns regulate summer rentals closely. The charts cover the whole New York metro. Our vetted agent partner covers Nassau and Suffolk and works on flips, BRRRR, buy-and-hold, land, new construction and commercial deals.

Fix & flip

Value-add purchases and resales across Nassau and Suffolk, where older housing stock and high resale prices leave room for a renovation spread.

BRRRR and buy & hold

Buy, renovate, rent and refinance, or hold long term. Expect thin or negative cash flow at Long Island prices and New York's tenant rules; this is mainly an equity play.

Land, development and new construction

Lot purchases, teardowns and new builds. Our partner works land, development and new construction.

Commercial

Commercial and mixed-use property in Nassau and Suffolk counties.

Areas our agents cover
Nassau CountySuffolk County
Shops and apartment buildings along a street in downtown Long Beach, New York
Downtown Long Beach, a walkable south-shore town with LIRR service to the city.Photo: Antony-22, CC BY-SA 4.0
Aerial view of the Greater Port Jefferson area of Suffolk County
Suburban Suffolk County around Port Jefferson, where much of the island's single-family stock is.Photo: Doc Searls, CC BY 2.0
Main Street in Port Jefferson seen from the harbor
Port Jefferson's Main Street, a north-shore village with a ferry to Connecticut.Photo: Wusel007, CC BY-SA 3.0
Market signals

Is Long Island worth investing in? The long-term trends

People, jobs, rents and prices for the New York metro metro, straight from the Census Bureau, the Bureau of Labor Statistics and Zillow. Hover or tap a chart for exact values.

Metro population
+1.4% in 10 years, to 20.11M people
19M19M20M20M2010201420182022202520M
July 1 estimates; 2010–2019 are Census intercensal estimates, consistent with the 2020 Census. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates (New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro)
View data table
PeriodValue
201018,947,699
201119,174,702
201219,369,606
201319,543,927
201419,695,917
201519,833,335
201619,945,132
201720,031,102
201820,092,724
201920,133,111
202019,999,993
202119,704,474
202219,629,390
202319,788,976
202420,080,087
202520,112,448
Net move-ins from the rest of the U.S.
−2.84M net domestic movers since 2010
−400K−300K−200K−100K0201120142017202020232025
View data table
PeriodValue
2011-86,161
2012-111,777
2013-115,585
2014-146,459
2015-169,071
2016-197,835
2017-203,430
2018-198,717
2019-194,533
2020-216,810
2021-365,351
2022-320,942
2023-197,969
2024-148,905
2025-168,105
Jobs (total nonfarm)
+9.7% since 2015, about 885K jobs added
8M8.5M9M9.5M10M2010201420182022202510M
Annual average, complete years. Latest month: September 2026, 10,019,900 jobs (not seasonally adjusted). Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (total nonfarm)
View data table
PeriodValue
20108,358,000
20118,472,800
20128,608,800
20138,761,300
20148,947,000
20159,139,500
20169,302,700
20179,456,900
20189,588,800
20199,718,300
20208,770,400
20219,073,300
20229,606,600
20239,809,500
20249,967,100
202510,024,700
Typical rent
+59% since 2015, +4.2% over the past year
$2,000$2,500$3,000$3,500201520172019202220242026$3,546
Typical asking rent, all homes (smoothed). Source: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), New York, NY metro
View data table
PeriodValue
Dec 2015$2,314/mo
Dec 2016$2,361/mo
Dec 2017$2,387/mo
Dec 2018$2,454/mo
Dec 2019$2,535/mo
Dec 2020$2,309/mo
Dec 2021$2,713/mo
Dec 2022$2,971/mo
Dec 2023$3,092/mo
Dec 2024$3,218/mo
Dec 2025$3,364/mo
Sep 2026$3,546/mo
Typical home value
+67% over 10 years, +4.9% over the past year
$200K$400K$600K$800K201020132016202020232026$731K
Typical home value, mid-tier, seasonally adjusted. Source: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), New York, NY metro
View data table
PeriodValue
Dec 2010$392,335
Dec 2011$375,878
Dec 2012$375,955
Dec 2013$392,566
Dec 2014$410,546
Dec 2015$428,393
Dec 2016$443,126
Dec 2017$468,225
Dec 2018$488,803
Dec 2019$501,930
Dec 2020$529,335
Dec 2021$582,130
Dec 2022$612,893
Dec 2023$638,507
Dec 2024$683,605
Dec 2025$705,793
Sep 2026$730,949
Price-to-rent ratio
17.2× today, down from a 19.5× peak in 2021
14×16×18×20×20152017201920222024202617.2×
Typical home value ÷ 12 months of typical rent. Lower means rents cover more of the price. Source: Agents Invest calculation from Zillow ZHVI and ZORI
View data table
PeriodValue
Dec 201515.4×
Dec 201615.6×
Dec 201716.3×
Dec 201816.6×
Dec 201916.5×
Dec 202019.1×
Dec 202117.9×
Dec 202217.2×
Dec 202317.2×
Dec 202417.7×
Dec 202517.5×
Sep 202617.2×

Data retrieved November 16, 2026. Figures cover the New York metro metro area.

Investing in Long Island

The numbers and rules that matter in Long Island

Typical home value
~$731,000

Zillow Home Value Index, New York metro metro, Sep 2026 (+4.9% YoY).

Typical rent
~$3,550/mo

Zillow Observed Rent Index, all home types, Sep 2026 (+4.2% YoY). Single-family 3-beds rent higher.

Monthly rent-to-price
~0.49%

Typical rent ÷ typical home value. Well under the 1% rule; plan on cash flow from buying right, not from rents.

Direction
Rising

Over the past year: home values +4.9%, rents +4.2%.

Local costs and rules

Security deposit cap
1 month's rent

New York Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019.

Deposit return deadline
14 days

Return the deposit or give an itemized statement within 14 days after move-out, or lose the right to keep any of it.

Late fee cap
$50 or 5%

Whichever is less, and only after rent is more than five days late (Real Property Law § 238-a).

Rent demand before filing
14 days

Written rent demand before a nonpayment case (RPAPL § 711).

New York landlord-tenant basics on Long Island

New York's 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act rewrote most of the statewide rules. On Long Island, towns and villages add their own rental permit rules, and some buildings fall under rent stabilization. The points investors ask about most:

  • Security deposit: capped at one month's rent. Within 14 days after the tenant moves out, return it or give an itemized statement of deductions. Miss the deadline and you lose the right to keep any of it.
  • Late fees: rent isn't late until it's more than five days past due, and the fee can't exceed $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is less (Real Property Law § 238-a).
  • Nonpayment: before filing, serve a written rent demand giving the tenant at least 14 days to pay (RPAPL § 711). The demand must also say whether the unit is covered by Good Cause Eviction.
  • Rent increases and non-renewal: New York requires advance written notice before raising the rent by 5% or more or not renewing a lease, with longer notice for longer tenancies. Check the current notice periods with the Attorney General's tenants' rights guide before you send one.
  • Good Cause Eviction: the 2024 state law applies automatically only in New York City. Towns, villages and cities elsewhere must opt in. As of November 2026, no Nassau or Suffolk municipality had opted in, but tenant groups have pushed Long Island villages to, so check the current list from NY Homes and Community Renewal.
  • Rent stabilization: some municipalities outside New York City, including some Nassau County villages, have opted into the Emergency Tenant Protection Act, which can put older buildings with six or more units under rent stabilization. Check the building's status with NY Homes and Community Renewal before you buy multifamily.
  • Rental permits: many Long Island towns and villages require a rental permit or registration, often with an inspection, before you rent a house or an accessory apartment. Rules and fees differ by town and by incorporated village inside each town. Confirm with the town and, if the property is in a village, the village.

Short-term rental rules on Long Island

Long Island has no single STR rule. Each town and village sets its own, and the East End towns, including Southampton and East Hampton, regulate summer rentals closely. State tax and registry rules apply everywhere.

  • Local rules: many Long Island towns and villages limit or ban rentals of less than a set minimum stay, require a rental permit or registry entry, or both. Check the town code, and the village code if the property is in an incorporated village, before you buy for an STR.
  • The Hamptons: Southampton and East Hampton both have rental registry and permit laws aimed at summer rentals. Confirm the current permit, registry and minimum-stay rules with the town before you underwrite summer income.
  • Sales tax: since March 1, 2025, New York State and local sales tax applies to short-term rental stays. Booking platforms that facilitate the stay must collect it.
  • County registry: state law requires each county to set up a short-term rental registry unless it opts out by local law, and hosts register with their county. Check whether Nassau or Suffolk runs one.
  • Condo, co-op and HOA rules can prohibit STRs regardless of town law.

Last reviewed November 15, 2026. General information, not legal or tax advice — rules and fees change, so confirm with the city, the statute, or your attorney before you rely on them. Sources: Zillow Research data (ZHVI, ZORI) — New York metro; NY Attorney General — Residential Tenants' Rights Guide; NY Real Property Law § 238-a — Late fees; NY RPAPL § 711 — Grounds for summary proceedings (rent demand); NY Attorney General — New York State Good Cause Eviction Law; NY Homes and Community Renewal — Good Cause Eviction; NY Senate — Good Cause Eviction adopted by 17 municipalities (2025); News12 Long Island — Tenants call for stronger renter protections at village hall rally (Dec 2025); NY Homes and Community Renewal — Rent stabilization and ETPA; NY Department of Taxation and Finance — Sales tax on short-term rental unit occupancy; NY Senate Bill S820 (2025) — County short-term rental registries.

Related guides
Nearby market guides
Long Island FAQ

Questions investors ask about Long Island

Which areas does your Long Island agent cover?

+

Our vetted agent partner covers Nassau County and Suffolk County and works on fix-and-flips, BRRRR, buy-and-hold, land and development, new construction and commercial property. Tell us your strategy, budget and target town and we'll match you.

Is Long Island a good place to buy rental property?

+

For equity, it can be; for cash flow, rarely. Long Island prices and property taxes are high enough that a median-priced long-term rental in Nassau or Suffolk won't cover a mortgage, and New York's tenant laws are strict. Investors who do well here buy below market and add value through renovation, BRRRR or new construction.

Does Long Island have rent control?

+

Partly. There's no general rent control, but some municipalities outside New York City, including some Nassau County villages, have opted into the state's Emergency Tenant Protection Act, which can put older buildings with six or more units under rent stabilization. New York's 2024 Good Cause Eviction law applies only where a municipality opts in, and we found no Long Island town or village that had as of November 2026.

What are New York's security deposit rules?

+

New York caps security deposits at one month's rent under the 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act. The landlord must return the deposit or give an itemized statement of deductions within 14 days after the tenant moves out, or lose the right to keep any of it. Late fees are capped at $50 or 5% of the rent, whichever is less.

Are short-term rentals legal on Long Island?

+

It depends on the town and village. Many Long Island municipalities require rental permits or minimum stays, and Southampton and East Hampton have rental registry and permit laws aimed at summer rentals. Statewide, New York sales tax has applied to short-term rental stays since March 1, 2025, and counties must run host registries unless they opt out. Check the local code for the exact address.

How much are property taxes on Long Island?

+

Among the highest in the United States. Nassau and Suffolk tax bills combine county, town, village and school district levies, and school taxes are usually the largest part. A bill can change when a property sells or when the seller's exemptions such as STAR drop off, so get the actual tax bill and ask what it will be for you as an investor owner before you offer.

Do I need a rental permit on Long Island?

+

Often, yes. Many Long Island towns and incorporated villages require landlords to get a rental permit or register the rental, usually with an inspection, before renting a house or an accessory apartment. Rules and fees vary by town and village, so check both for the specific property.

What does it cost to get matched with a Long Island agent?

+

Nothing. Agents Invest is free for investors. The agent pays us a referral fee only if you close a deal with them.

Find your Long Island investor agent

Tell us what you're buying or selling in the Long Island area. We'll match you with up to three vetted agents who fit your strategy. Free for investors.

Get matched with an agent